Pet-friendly Hotels in Shelter Island, NY

Enjoy exclusive use of an outdoor jacuzzi and cabana at this pet-friendly apartment, located just three blocks from the beach in Greenport.
This newly renovated two-bedroom apartment is situated in Greenport, offering excellent walkability with the village and Shelter Island Ferry just one block away, and the beach three blocks away.

Located in Pipes Cove, Greenport, this historic waterfront cottage offers direct access to Peconic Bay and a private beach, just a short walk from downtown Greenport Village's shops and restaurants.
This pet-friendly cottage boasts 850 square feet of living space, accommodating up to 4 guests with 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, and features a garden, spa, and kitchen, making it ideal for family fun and outdoor activities like sailing and fishing.

Centrally located in Greenport village, this apartment is just steps from Front and Main streets, offering convenient access to local restaurants and activities, with a bay view.
This pet-friendly apartment features a private, enclosed backyard with a heated saltwater pool and grill, perfect for up to six guests and two dogs, and is located just 500 feet from the water.